Investigation Reports

Description	Date
Investigation Reports 2013/2014
Report No. 16 of 2011/12 of the Public protector on an investigation into alleged improper salary deductions implemented by the Author-General South Africa	17 May 2013
Report No :5 of 2013/14 on an investigation into a complaint of improper prejudice caused by the refusal of the Department of Correctional Services to apply to National Treasury for a Persal deduction code	24 April 2013
Report No :4 of 2013/14 on an investigation into the alleged undue delay by the Ngwathe Local Municipality to pay a service provider	24 April 2013
Report No :3 of 2013/14 on an investigation into the alleged incorrect calculation of the pension benefits against the Eastern Cape Department of Education	24 April 2013
Report No :2 of 2013/14 on an investigation into the maladministration by the Eastern Cape Gambling and Betting Board in relation to appointment of the Chief Executive Officer of the Board	23 April 2013
Report No :1 of 2013/14 on an investigation into the alleged abuse of power by Director - General of the Department of Trade and Industry towards the former Commissioner of the National Consumer Commission	24 April 2013
Investigation Reports 2012/2013
Report No :23 of 2012/13 on an investigation into the alleged failure by the Deartment of Justice and Constitutional Development to protect a whistleblower(an employee) who made a protected disclosure in terms of the Protected Disclosure Act,2000	07 February 2013
Report no 22 of 2012/2013 of the Public Protector on a systematic investigation into alleged deficiencies in theprocessing of appesl spplications referred to Lergal Aid South Africa's Mahikeng Justice Centre	01 February 2013
Report No: 21 of 2012/2013 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of nepotism and non-compliance with the Employment Equity Plan at the Drakensteim Municipality	04 February 2013
Report No. 20 of 2012/2013 of the Public Protector on an Investigation into the Allegations of Maladministration by Bloemwater for failure to comply with the Decision of its Internal Appeal Authority and a award of the South African Local Government Bargaining Council	31 January 2013
Report No: 19 of 2012/2013 of the Public Protector on in Investigation into an allegation of improper conduct and unfair treatment by the City of Cape Town relating to damage caused as a result of an electrical power surge Report No: 19 of 2012/2013	31 January 2013
Report No.17 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into the allegations of negligence by the City of Ekurhuleni which allegedly resulted in prejudice to Mr. Malahlela	14 December 2012
Report No.16 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into the alleged improper procurement of Erf 246, Roggebaai, Cape Town by the City of Cape Town	04 December 2012
Report No.15 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into an allegation of a Breach of the Executive Ethics Code by the Member responsible for Finance, Economic Affairs and Tourism of the Executive Council of the Northern Cape Provincial Government, Mr J Block, relating to the sale of municipal land by the Sol Plaatje Municipality in Kimberley	26 November 2012
Report No.14 of 2012/13of the Public Protector on an investigation into an allegation of a breach of the Executive Ethics Code by the Premier of the Northern Cape Province, Ms H Jenkins, relating to the sale of municipal land by the Sol Plaatje Municipality in Kimberley	26 November 2012
Report No.13 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of maladministration and poor governance by the Ehlazeni District Municipality in the Mpumalanga Province	26 November 2012
Report No.12 of 2012/13of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of maladministration and improper conduct by the Department of Mineral Resources pertaining to the procurement of services	26 November 2012
Report No.10 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of impropriety and corrupt practices relating to the awarding of contracts for goods and services by the Limpopo Department of Roads and Transport	10 October 2012
Report No.9 of 2012/13of the Public Protector on an Investigation into Allegations of Alleged Abuse of State Power Resulting in the Alleged Unlawful Arrest and Detention by an Off-Duty Traffic Police Officer	October 2012
Report No.8 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into an allegation of incorrect billing for municipal services against the Ba-Phalaborwa Municipality	10 October 2012
Report No.5 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector in terms of section 182(1)(b) of the constitution of the Republic of South Africa , 1996 and section 8 (1) of the Public Protector Act, 1994	September 2012
Report No.4 of 2012/13 of the Public protector on an investigation into the allegation of the improper involvement of the Depauty President of the Republic of South in a business transactrion with the Islamic Republic of Iran	September 2012
A provisional report No.3 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of a breach of the Executives Ethics Code by the Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fishers, Ms TinaJoemat-Petterson, MP	26 November 2012
Report No.1 of 2012/13 of the Public Protector on an investigation into the alleged improper procurement of communication services by the Department of the Premier of the Western Cape Provincial Government	01 June 2012
Investigation Reports 2011
Report No. 21 of 2011/2012 of the Public Protector on an investigation into alleged abuse of power and maladministration by the Department of Home Affairs in respect of an application for the renewal or extension of work and other permits submitted by Mr. M Van Hillegondsberg and family	April 2012
Report No. 20 of 2011/12 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of improper conduct by the former Member responsible for Health and Social Development of the Executive Council of the Limpopo Provincial Government relating to the procurement of services for the Limpopo Department of health	29 February 2012
Report No.19 of 2011/12 of the Public Protector on an investigation into the alleged unlawful and unconstitutional funding of political parties by the Moqhaka Local Municipality in the Free State Province	24 April 2012
Report No. 19 of 2011/2012 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegations of maladministration and poor governance by the Dipaleseng Local Municipality, the South African Police Service and the Mpumalanga Departments of Human Settlements and Public Works	29 February 2012
Report No. 17 of 2011/2012 of the Public Protector on an investigation in connection with the alleged irregular appointment of the special advisor, Dr P Ngobeni	20 March 2012
Report No. 18 of 2011/2012 of the Public Protector on an investigation into allegation of improper conduct by the Department of Public Service and Administration and the Government Employees Pension Fund during the privatisation of the Venda Pension Fund	November 2011
Report of the Public protector on an investigation into complaints of maladministration against the Midvaal Local Municipality	October 2011
Report no. 13 of 2011/12: An Investigation into an alleged breach of Section 2 (2) (a) (i) and (2(2)(b)(ii) and (v) of the Executive Member's Ethics Act and the Executive Ethics Code by the Premier of Gauteng, Ms NP Mokonyane	28 September 2011
Report No. 12 of 2011/12: Report on an investigation into alleged poor service delivery at the Gugulethu Community Health Centre (Western Cape Department of Health)	28 September 2011
Report No 11 of 2011/12 of the Public Protector on an Investigation into Allegations of a Breach of the Executive Ethics Code by the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Mr Sicelo Shiceka, MP	2011
Report No: 10 of 2011/2012: Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Improper Conduct and Maladministration by the Department of Correctional Services with Regard to the early retirement of a Former Employee Mr T E Ntsane.	28 September 2011
Report 9 of 2011/2012 of the Public Protector on an investigation into a complaint of conflict of interest against Mr. J. Manyi	28 September 2011
Report on an Investigation into Complaints and Allegations of Maladministration, improper and Unlawful Conduct by the Department of Public Works and the South African Police Services (SAPS) Relating to the Leasing of SAPS Office Accommodation in Durban	14 July 2011
Report on an Investigation into the Alleged Improper Soliciting of Businesses for Donations to the African National Congress by Mr C Taute, Executive Mayor of the Hessequa Municipality	June 2011
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of the Submission of Incorrect Pension Exit Documents to the Government Pensions Administration Agency by the Eastern Cape Provincial Department of Education as well as Failure by North West Provincial Department of Education to Process and Submit the Pension Exit Documents of Mrs Nothando Cecilia Jada, Timeously	21 February 2011
Report on an Investigation into Complaints and Allegations of Maladministration, Improper and Unlawful Conduct by the Department of Public Works and The South African Police Service Relating to the Leasing of Office Accommodation in Pretoria	23 February 2011
Investigation Reports 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegation of Failure and/or Refusal to Disclose the Cause of Death of a Patient by the Chris Hani-Baragwanath Hospital	2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the Department of Education in the Eastern Cape Province Failed to Submit Correct Exit Documents for Mr K W Nyamani to the Government Employees Pension Fund	2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Undue Delay by the South African Police Service in the Investigation of a Criminal Case of Rape of a Minor	25 November 2010
Report on a Negotiated Settlement of a Dispute Involving the Drakenstein Municipality and Ms M I Mashiqa Pertaining to the Damage Caused to her Property by a Municipal Vehicle by a Municipal Employee	25 November 2010
Report on a Negotiated Settlement of a Dispute Involving the Drakenstein Municipality and Mrs N E Xhosa Pertaining to the Damage Caused to her Household Electrical Appliances by an Electrical Power Surge	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into the Alleged Improper Refusal to Admit a Learner to Milnerton High School	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into Alleged Failure by the Western Cape Department of Health to Proper Health Care to a Disabled Person	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Undue Delay in the Rectification and Issuing of an Identity Document by the Department of Home Affairs, Eastern Cape Province	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Alleged Undue Delay by the South African Police Service to Process and Submit Pension Exit Documents of Mr Volker to the Government Employees Pension Fund	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into Alleged Undue Delay or Refusal by the Department Of Minerals and Energy to Refusal by the Mzintlava Community is Compensated for Losses Suffered as a Result of the Mining Operations of the Mzintlava Quarry	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into a Complaint of Improper Conduct by the Governing Body of the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and the Prejudice Caused by Its Decision not to Accredit a Panelist of Bargaining Councils	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Poor Service Delivery by the Steve Tshwete Municipality in failing to Assist the Beneficiaries of Low Cost Subsidy Houses with the Acquisition of Title Deeds	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Undue Delay Relating to the Submission of Pension Documents to the Government Employees of a Payment of Pension Benefits to the Beneficiaries of a Former Employee of the Department of Education of the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Government, the late Khumalo	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Maladministration Relating to the Allocation of Rented Accommodation by the Mpumalanga Provincial Department of Education	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Improper Conduct by the then Acting Municipal Manager of the Nkomazi Local Municipality in Termination an Investigation by the Integrity Management Unit Without Authority	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into the Allegation of Maladministration Prejudice by the Commercial Crime Unit in Pietermaritzburg: Kwazulu-Natal Province Involving Failure to Process Documents of a Victim of Crime	25 November 2010
Report on an Investigation into Complaints Relating to Misconduct and Maladministration in Connection with the Affairs of the Commission for Gender Equality	08 October 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the Mpumalanga Provincial Department of Education Improperly Suspended the Salary of an Educator	20 August 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of a Breach of the Executive Members' ethics Act, 1998 and the Executive ethics Code by the Minister of Communications, General Siphiwe Nyanda (RET)	17 August 2010
Report on Investigation Into Complaints Relating to the Proper Awarding of Tenders by Municipalities in the Limpopo and North West Provinces	17 August 2010
Report on an Investigation into the Alleged Erregular Issuing of a Mining permit to Elitheni Coal mine by the Department of Mineral Resources in the Eastern Cape Province	21 July 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Maladministration Relating to the Appointment Ms C M Jacobs by the Northern Cape Provincial Department of Health	5 July 2010
Report on an Investigation Into the Alleged Failure by the North West Department of Transport, Roads, and Community Safety to Pay for the Transportation of Learners to the Calvyn Primary School in Schweizer-Reneke	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into An Allegation Of Irregular Expenditure In The Procurement Of New Furniture For Offices Of Council Chambers, Nketoana Local Municipality, Free State Province	10 June 2010
Report On A Systemic Investigation Into Allegations Of Poor Service Delivery By The Compensation Fund (part 1)	10 June 2010
Report On A Systemic Investigation Into Allegations Of Poor Service Delivery By The Compensation Fund (part 2)	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into The Failure By The Former Deputy Provincial Commissioner Of The South African Police Service For Gauteng To Investigate An Allegation Of Criminal Activities Committed By Certain Members Of The South African Police Service And The Public	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into The Alleged Failure By The Departments Of Education Of The Limpopo And Free State Provincial Governments To Pay The Medical Aid Subsidy Owed To An Employee	10 June 2010
Report On An Own Initiative Investigation Into A SABC News Report On Poor Service Delivery By The Thembisile Local Municipality To Residents Of Block 17: Moloto Village In The Mpumalanga Province	10 June 2010
An Investigation Into Allegations Of Improper Conduct And Mal-Administration By The MEC And The Head Of The Department For Safety And Liason In The Eastern Cape Province	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Of Alleged Unfair Conduct By The City Of Cape Town In Connection With The Transfer Of A Municipal Housing Tenancy	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into An Alleged Failure By The Dr Js Moroka Municipality To Assist Mr Ds Sokhulu To Amend His Deed Of Grant	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Allegations Of Undue Delay In Processing Payment For Relief Teaching Services Rendered By Ms G V Mooketsi To The Department Of Education In The North West Province	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Allegations Of Maladministration And Undue Delay Relating To The Submission Of Pension Documents Of A Former Employee Of The Limpopo Provincial Department Of Education, Ms C Bredell, To The Government Employees Pension Fund	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Allegations Of Undue Delay In The Registration Of A Foreign Qualified Healthcare Professional	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Alleged Unlawful Disposal Of Medical Waste And Discourteous Conduct Of Staff At The G F Jooste Hospital	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Allegations Of Undue Delay By The South African Police Service To Process And Submit Pension Documents In Respect Of The Late L D Mokoena To The Government Employees Pension Fund	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into An Allegation That The National Prosecuting Authority Failed To Discharge Its Mandate As Recommended By The Truth And Reconciliation Commission	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into An Allegation Of Undue Delay In The Payment Of Leave Gratuity After Retirement Of An Educator By The Gauteng Provincial Department Of Education	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into Allegations Of Failure By Eastern Cape Provincial Department Of Education To Provide Additional Classrooms And Toilet Structures For Ntekelelo Junior Secondary School	10 June 2010
Report On An Investigation Into An Allegation Of The Misappropriation Of Public Funds By The Former Free State Youth Commission	10 June 2010
Report Of On An Investigation Into An Alleged Breach Of Section 5 Of The Executive Ethics Code By President JG Zuma	21 April 2010
Report Of On An Investigation Into Allegations of Failure to Register the Birth of a Child and the Naturalisation of the Mother by the Northern Cape Department of Home Affairs	March 2010
Report on a Despute Involving the Theewaterskloof Municipality and Mr J C Schickeling Partaining to the Damage Caused to his Household Electrical Appliances by an Electrical Power Surge	March 2010
Report Of On An Investigation Into An Alleged Refusal by the South African Board for Sheriffs to Institute a Disciplinary Enquiry into the Conduct of the Sheriff for Wynburg North	March 2010
Report on an investigation into an Allegation of an Undue Delay in the Processing of an Appeal Application by Moretele Magistrates court, Due to Missing Case Records	March 2010
Report on a Negotiated Settlement of a Dispute of a Involving the Department of Public Works and Mr G N Lawrence Regarding the Sale of a Portion of ERF 634, Simon's Town and Other Related Matters	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of the Maladministration and Corruption at Kopanong Munipality, Free State Province	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Maladministration and due delay by the Master of the High Court, Bloemfontein in Remitting Payment of Pension Benefits held in the Guardian's Fund	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the South African Social Security Agency Suspended Payment of a Child Support Grant Without Furnishing Written Reasons	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into Alleged Undue delay on the Part of the Western Cape Education Department to Address Conditions at the Duneside Primary School, Mitchell's Plain	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Impropriety that Relate to the Mooifontein Animal Pound in the North West Province	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Undue delay by the Legal Aid Board and Klerksdorp Magistrates Court in Processing a Criminal Appeal of Mr Matiti	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the Mpumalanga Provincial Department of Education Improperly Suspended the Salary of an Educator	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the South African Police Service Improperly Held Mr Hleza Liable for Payment of a DNA Test	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into the Alleged Irregular Appointment of a Headman in Tsengiwe by the Member of the Executive Council Responsible for Local Government and Traditional Affairs in the Eastern Cape Province	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of the Miscalculation of Leave days of Employees in the Department of Water and Environmental Affairs	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the Steve Tshwete Municipality in the Mpumalanga Province Failure to Respond to Complaints and Representations Received from Mr M Joubert	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Failure to Keep Records of Applications for RDP Houses by the Ngqushwa Local Municipality, Eastern Cape Province	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Failure by the CCMA to Issue an Arbitration Award in Terms of the Labour Relations ACT, 1995	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of the Improper Sale of Land by the Kai! Garib Municipality, in the Northern Cape Province	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into the Alleged undue delay and Refusal by the Western Cape Provincial Department of Education and Chapel Street Primary School in the Cape Town to Remunerate a Temporary Employee for Services Rendered	25 February 2010
Report on an Investigation into an Alleged unfair Language Practices of the Matzikama Municipality	25 February 2010
Investigation Reports 2009
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation that the South African Police Service failed to pay a Reward to an Informer after undertaking to do so.	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation of a Complaint by Residents of Units R and S Lebowakgomo against the Department of Local Government and Housing, Limpopo Province, in Connection with Applications for Housing Subsidies	18 February 2009
Report on an own Initiative Investigation into an Allegation that the South African Social Security Agency Suspended the Social Security Grant of Ms N S Mphephu without good cause	18 February 2009
Report on a Preliminary Investigation relating to Electricity Load Shedding Implemented by Eskom Holdings Limited	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Improper Conduct by the former Chairperson of The Board of Directors of Eskom Holdings Limited, Mr V Moosa, relating to the Awarding of a Contract	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of the Improper Deduction of Pension Benefits of a former member of the South African Police Service and the Identification of Systemic Deficiencies in the Practices and Procedures for the Recovery of Departmental Debt from Pension Benefits	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of the Misappropriation of Public Funds by The Deputy Minister of Home Affairs, Mr M K N Gigaba MP	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Abuse of Power, Breach of Trust and Favouritism made against the Member of the Executive Council Responsible for Education of the Limpopo Provincial Government, and of the Violation of Supply Chain Management Regulations by Officials of the Limpopo Department of Education	18 February 2009
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of Misappropriation of Public Funds by the Gauteng Provincial Department of Social Development	18 February 2009
Investigation Reports 2008
Report of the Public Protector in terms of Section 182(1)(B) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 and Sections 8(1) and 8(2)(B)(I) of the Public Protector Act, 1994	20 August 2008
Report of the Public Protector in terms of Section 182(1)(B) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 and Section 8(1) of the Public Protector Act, 1994	20 August 2008
Report of the Public Protector in terms of Section 182(1)(B) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 and Sections 8(1) and 8(2)(B)(I) of the Public Protector Act, 1994	20 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Mismanagement of Public Funds Granted to the Tirisano Development Group by the North West Department of Health	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into the Allegations of Impropriety by the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development for Failure and/or Refusal to Submit Proper Court Records to the Director of Public Prosecutions for Appeal Purposes	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Undue Delay by the Medical Bureau for Occupational Diseases in Certification of Applications for Compensation for Diagnosed Mine Related Occupational Diseases	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of an Undue Delay by the Office of the Master of the High Court, Pretoria, in Investigating the Legality and Feasibility of the Contracts Regarding the Harvesting of Trees by the Shakoaneng Community Trust	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation by the Public Protector on Allegations that the Principal of Thamagane Primary School Irregularly Inflated the Number of Learners at the School	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Maladministration and Undue Delay Relating to the Payment of Pension Benefits to a Former Employee of the Department of Education of the Limpopo Provincial Government	01 August 2008
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Maladministration and Undue Delay Relating to the Payment of Pension Benefits to a Former Member of the South African Police Service	01 August 2008
Report on the Investigation of an Allegation of Improper Conduct by the Minister of Public Service and Administration, Ms G J Fraser-Moleketi, Relating to the Acceptance Of A Gift	16 May 2008
Report on an Investigation into an Allegation of the Misappropriation of Public Funds by the Department of Health	16 May 2008
Report on the Implementation of the Recommendations Made in the Report of the Public Protector on an Investigation into Allegations of Non-Compliance by the Premier of the Free State Provincial Government with the Provisions of the Free State Youth Commission Act, 1996	13 May 2008
Report on an Investigation into Allegations of Maladministration against the National Department of Social Development and the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Department of Social Services and Population Development	13 May 2008